I am the kind of person who isn't comfortable not knowing why I feel certian ways about certain things. Por ejemplo; Music has always been a big part of my life. I used to wonder as a kid why I loved certain song I heard on the radio. I would try to love the other songs as well and they usually grew on me 'cause , hey, I'm a kid and I don't know any better.
As I got older and started to pick up the guitar, this slowly stopped working. I started to wonder what was different about the music I loved and the rest of the music that I didn't love. Or the music that I heard and liked at first but then I got tired of. Or the music I din't care for at first but then grew to love. I didn't realize it at the time, but, what I was searching for was a kind of philisophical holy grail: unity in diversity. We get the words universe and university from these two words. The job of the university was to find unity in diversity. In other words I was searching for the unifying factor in the diversity of the music that I loved.
I have always had eclectic tastes so stlye went right out the window right away. I did notice a strong theme in the meledy. Meledy in a song/composition was always what drew me in so I tried to analyze writing styles and though maybe the melodies of the songs I loved were composed first and then the harmonies were added or maybe the lyrics were written first and then the music was added, but none of these theories comforted me. I could use these as a yardstick to judge new music I heard to tell that it would have staying power.
Then something funny happened a few years ago. I had stopped even thinking about the whole thing when it started to make perfect sense. I guess the psychologists call it the byscociating mind. I got comfortable when I started thing about the people behind the music I love. The unifier was in the artist not in the art. What is the artist about? Good philosophy? Gifted musician? What do they value? Do I consistanly love the work of their entire career? I also noticed how similar these answers where to the answers I would give to these questions in regfard to myself; the artists I love were alot like me. Not across the board but in general. I also noticed the nigh amounts of critical aclaim my favorites got. Like Zappa, Steely Dan, Rush, Gentle Giant, Ben Folds, Seal, Mike Keneally, and others. I realized that I had found a rule to gauge pretty quickly weather some new music I heard, or I should say some new artist I heard would last with me.
Stay tuned for part two!